The Hotel New Hampshire by John Irving (1981)
This is the second John Irving book I’ve raised the flag for (A Prayer For Owen Meaney was the first). I do not know of any other recent American author as adept at creating his own universe as Irving. And for some his work is quirkiness smothered by oddities and first rate paradoxes. Yet he maintains a believable reality even though it is far removed from what most of us experience in life.
The tale centers on the highly eccentric Berry family and is narrated by the middle child of five, John. There is death, creepy taxidermy, incest, rape, political intrigue, blindness, prostitution, closeted homosexuality, ‘nad kicking, terrorism and a Bear named State O’Maine involved in the work. It takes special talent to weave a narrative that not only makes sense from all this but excels in doing so. A tapestry of the mind, one which you find yourself adding to the swoop of the loom. You find yourselves caring about these people despite their half-crazy latching onto the various Big Ideas of the father–who is a bit of a fool, but he’s an ingratiating and interesting fool.
To underscore the depth of Irving’s talent, he is able to carry the tale via John who is madly in love with his older sister and wants to screw her (let us not play with words or serve pablum such as “make love”). I guess, in a very real way, Irving was able to find the only possible filament of acceptability to that situation and got it across, although this reader was happy when that stopped being a main theme.
There are, in fact, three Hotel New Hampshires, whose appearances gave the novel its linear shape. Yet other than the names of the places and that they were hotels in the technical sense, none of the three was like any of the others.
The star of Irving’s work is Irving himself. He does not intrude on the story, and although he tells it in the first person, I never gained a feeling that he was speaking to me through a puppet character, as too many authors do. His ability to make these nut jobs believable and sympathetic no matter what they do, and without resorting to sentimentality is the reason why he lives in a mansion somewhere. He has been able to thrive by creating stories about human beings doing human stuff. He does it with wit, humour, intelligence and even a bit of ruthlessness toward characters when they are no longer needed.
I’ve reached a strange appreciation of Irving–I find that I admire his stories more than I like them, which may sound odd, I suppose, but it is true. Maybe that is because, for me, “like” is a settled final quality, the last part of a decision, while admiration is an ongoing process (gadzooks, how I hate what the modern time has done to “process”). I find myself re-evaluating and thinking about New Hampshire often (and Owen Meaney–but not Garp because my admiration could not save that one for me). Few authors will visit my thoughts long after I have read them, and by God, that is a triumph.

Leila
This is a great companion piece to your review of Owen Meany. I devoured this novel when I was a junior in high school and loved it to death. What I remember about it most is the characters. I remember LIKING the characters a ton, AND feeling for them (happy when they were happy and sad when they were sad, etc.). I was utterly fascinated by the relationship between the brother and the sister because it seemed perverse and even illegal and yet he told the tale as if it were pure, okay, and all-natural. I wonder what would happen if a white male tried to tell such a tale in such a way now? SO much has changed since the early ’80s, both for good, and for ill.
In The Sound and the Fury by Faulkner the main character kills himself, mostly because of his feelings for his sister, which are not even consummated!
This is also one of those novels I have not looked at since I first read it over forty years ago. I wonder what I would think about it now. Back then, I thought Irving was an American Charles Dickens.
I’m sure I would still like the novel, but I wonder if I would still love it as much as I did then. I think I will take a trip to the library and pick up a copy to see what I think, thanks to you!
Dale
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Dale
I for one liked it better the second time. There is somethin hilarious about the Dad saying auf wedersen (sp) Fritz over and again, despite the heaviness of the moment. Irving creates these wierd pockets in the universe, which, I think will outlast politics. Arts defeats Politics like paper beats rock!
Thank you! Leila
LikeLike
I read Hotel New Hampshire years ago and enjoyed it. Didn’t like the movie though. Didn’t Jodie Foster play the bear?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi David
I got a lucky break and was warned off the film by two people I respect. I can’t see how an Irving story can be told in two hours. From what I hear it wasn’t! Jodie Foster has a way of being very good in very bad movies. “Stealing Home” comes to mind.
Thank you!
Leila
LikeLiked by 1 person